beehiiv paywall

A newsletter platform to write, send, grow and earn from an email newsletter.

beehiiv

Onboarding checklist and a ticking trial offer

The upsell stays out of the way in a header pill with a live countdown, while the page focuses on getting your newsletter set up.

B2CactivationpaywallNov 2026

01

Dashboard checklist

Setup comes first and the offer stays peripheral, but the countdown makes sure you notice it.

beehiiv: Dashboard checklist
  1. 1

    Countdown pill (working)

    "10% off forever ends in 22:55:15": a live timer in a calm spot.

    Urgency

  2. 2

    1 of 7 already done (working)

    Account creation counts as a step, so you start with progress.

    Endowed progress effect

  3. 3

    Human copy (working)

    "Add your aunt and best friend… your first 10 subscribers matter most."

    Specificity

  4. 4

    Tiny first win (working)

    "Write a quick hello and send a preview to your inbox."

    Time to value

  5. 5

    Hideable checklist (working)

    It also says where to find it again later.

    User control and freedom

  6. 6

    Sidebar overload on day one (not working)

    Ad Network, Products, Tip jar and Paid recommendations, before you have a single reader.

    Choice overload

02

Claim offer → Compare plans

The plans modal scales prices to your audience and points you at Pro.

beehiiv: Claim offer → Compare plans
  1. 7

    Price by subscriber count (working)

    A slider ties price to your audience size, the value metric that matters.

    Value metric pricing

  2. 8

    Only Pro gets the dark CTA (working)

    One button stands out, so the target plan is unmistakable.

    Visual hierarchy

  3. 9

    "Everything on Lite, plus:" (working)

    Each tier lists only what's new, so comparing is easy.

    Progressive disclosure

  4. 10

    Timer still ticking (working)

    The countdown stays visible behind the modal.

    Urgency

  5. 11

    10% feels small (not working)

    $59 → $53.10 is a weak anchor; the odd cents read as computed, not generous.

    Anchoring

  6. 12

    Pro has no reason label (not working)

    Pro is emphasized but never says why, unlike "Most Popular" or "Recommended".

    Social proof

  7. 13

    The list runs below the fold (not working)

    Four columns of features continue past the modal's edge.

    Cognitive load

Takeaways from beehiiv

  1. Keep the upsell peripheral but alive: a countdown pill outperforms a blocking modal during setup.
  2. Start the checklist with a step already done.
  3. Price on the value metric (subscribers), and label the plan you want people to pick.